Tony D's - New Palestine, Indiana

Tony D's Restaurant Review

Located at 5918 Dragon Dr, New Palestine, IN 46163, Tony D's is a popular dining spot known for its great beer selection and delicious comfort food. With a 4/5 rating on Google based on 280 reviews, it's clear that this restaurant is a hit with patrons. Here are the key details you need to know about Tony D's:

Specialties: Tony D's is a restaurant that offers a broad range of options for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. They also have a great selection of beer, cocktails, and wine to complement your meal. The menu features comfort food with a twist, ensuring there's something for everyone.

Other points of interest: Tony D's provides several convenient options for dining, including outdoor seating, curbside pickup, no-contact delivery, delivery, takeout, dine-in, and fast service. The restaurant is also well-equipped to accommodate guests with disabilities, offering a wheelchair accessible entrance, parking lot, and restroom, as well as wheelchair accessible seating. They have a cozy and casual atmosphere that is perfect for solo diners, groups, and tourists. Reservations are accepted, and the restaurant is credit card and NFC mobile payment friendly. Children are welcome, and high chairs and a kids' menu are available. Parking is available in a free lot and on the street.

Opinions: Tony D's has received numerous positive reviews, with patrons praising the quality of the food, the pleasant atmosphere, and the attentive service. Some highlights include perfectly cooked steaks, delicious pulled pork nachos, and a pleasant ambiance with music that isn't too loud. Many guests comment on feeling satisfied and are eager to return for future meals. With a solid reputation and a diverse menu, Tony D's is a top choice for locals and visitors alike.

👍 Reviews of Tony D's

Jerrica M.

5/5

Very pleased with our food! The steak was done to perfection, pulled pork nachos sooo good not soggy like other reviews stated, pleasant atmosphere (came at a less busy time), music not as loud as some restaurants (my preference), waitress was lovely and we left feeling satisfied. Definitely coming back!

Geoffrey H.

4/5

Pretty solid breakfast/brunch spot in New Palestine. The service is really friendly and treat you like family. We went in the fall so were stuck inside which feels a little uncozy or sanitary or something but I did spot some garage-door-type windows that I assume they open when it's warm enough, which sounds great. The food was good, though the eggs were a little bland somehow. All around a good spot that I'll have to make my way back to in the summer!

Dillon D.

5/5

Food was excellent and wait staff was very pleasant and attentive. We stopped by on a whim and were very impressed with our visit. Some of the best fried pickles that I've had and the bathrooms were very nice and clean as well. I would definitely recommend and will be back for sure.

H. Y.

2/5

Busy new restaurant, locals supporting in an options starved area of mostly a few mainstay basic fast food and a traditional cuisines. Interior basic utilitarian decor and furniture, not upscale. Food options slight twists on normal favorites. But first time ever Reuben sandwich with add on charges for cheese, etc I’ve ever seen. What!!!! Rye bread as expected and corned beef seems home cooked not deli cut. Very minimal dressing nt enough. Right amount of sauerkraut. A bit disappointing could have been better. Did come with slightly generous side, I chose mashed potatoes and brown gravy. Heavy on butter/garlic? Other dish Beef Manhattan a huge disappointment. Insufficient gravy (what is a Beef Manhattan without more than enough gravy to soak the bread), beef a few slivers of probably precooked rewarmed dry ewww. Mashed potatoes with not enough gravy is a huge miss. Skimpiest Beef Manhattan I’ve ever seem. Third dish mediocre I’m not putting effort to type it in. Tony D’s not on my go to restaurant list, no wow factor to be had. Ok for locals but too many misses to bring guests. That’s all 2/5 not 3. Young male host very cordial the best part of the visit. The two gal hostesses who came up later not enthused very meh and unengaging.

K ?. A.

5/5

I ordered boneless wings, what I got was chunks of chicken breast deep fried (picture). I wanted the chili cheeseburger, but they don't have chili anymore. I wanted the fish & chips with onion rings (was willing to pay) but it comes with steak fries, NO substitutions. The menu needs serious consideration, I don't mind paying for what I want.

JoAnna F.

5/5

The staff are friendly and attentive. The Dragon’s Breath was delicious. The tenderloin was ok. We like the atmosphere with sports on the TVs. Definitely a favorite in town.

Dennis W.

5/5

First time here (wife’s second) very good food (pizza was awesome) wife had a chicken wrap/then a salad both were excellent. Will definitely be back. Service was great and food came out in a reasonable time considering it was 1/2–3/4 full.

Mack M.

3/5

Ok so I have loved Tony D's for the past 2 years, but the quality of food has changed. We stopped eating there last year due to the change in taste/quality. Ordered today through Door Dash (pulled pork nachos) and received them with mold on my jalapenos. Door Dash did give me a credit so I'm going to order from somewhere else, but I did call Tony D's just to inform the staff they had moldy produce so they could check it and get rid of it to which the lady replied "okay" like it was not unusual or no big deal. After I stated that it is a health hazard she again said okay and that she would let her manager know. I truly hope she did. Given I'm pregnant, having rotten food is kind of a big deal to me. Ijs, please address the quality issue because I've loved this place since I moved to New Pal.